Thursday, 26 March 2015

Use Our Resources to the Full

 Our movement, like every organisation, finds itself now and then at a crossroads. At our present crossroads, we can look back with a sense of pride and confidence that we have made a difference. We have shared our values, lived our lifestyle and influenced changes which have made the lives of many people more meaningful and worthwhile for generations.

What we do, where we go, and how we do whatever comes next is the purpose of these vision papers and we need both leaders and followers as we prepare for the future.

If we decide on anything worthwhile it will seem, almost certainly at first, beyond our ability and beyond our resources. This purpose of this short piece is to help us to look again at the resources we have. It is about money - but not just that.

The theological thinking that faith communities are about people and not buildings is beyond dispute; but our buildings are part of our resource package. If we have historic buildings we are probably better placed now than ever before to obtain grants and raise money to preserve them. As well as being the focus of most of what we do, they can also provide places to celebrate a variety of life milestones and be used as venues for musical concerts and events of many kinds. If our buildings are more modern and maybe modest, we can emphasise the beauty of the simplicity of the space they offer. With a little effort we can create a venue which people will want to use and be associated with.

The Church in Portsmouth where I have worked is a simple post-war building, but it offers an uncluttered and light space and makes an impact on almost everyone who visits it. Obviously our buildings are a resource for supplementing our income, but in addition they can speak to our purpose as well. For too long we have treated our buildings as a constricting noose around our neck when in fact they can be a beautiful necklace to attract both visitors and income.

As a movement and as individual congregations we have significant financial investments. For many years these have served us well and paid sufficient dividends to provide for a relatively easily funded operation. Recent global events have significantly altered this scenario and the likelihood is that we will not return to investment returns at the level they were for a long time if ever.

Most of these funds were given for specific restricted purposes and we will need to think and work hard at finding ways to use some of the capital as well as the income to serve these purposes. If we can't do this we may find we have missed the final window of opportunity. It would be a tragedy if Unitarianism in these Islands came to an end because financial resources were there but unable to be released to support existing and new congregations

This will not be easy of course, but there examples of congregations which have grappled with these issues and have made brave decisions. The result is that these visionaries are funding the human resource of Ministers and spiritual and skilled development leaders before it is too late.

Then of course there is the financial resource which we all have and which is still in our pockets. It has been said many times that if we could all give the cost of a couple of cups of decent coffee a week it would make a huge difference. In fact it would bring in over £710,000 a year that pretty well matches the annual income of the general Assembly (and it would also mean we could maximise the generous Bowland funding as well).

If the same number of people as our quota contributors gave an extra £5 a week it would raise over £825,000 and that could support another 24 full-time Ministers. Just suppose we make it three fewer glasses of wine a week at your local wine bar that's about £10 a week. That would provide £1.65 million and provide the income to run the General Assembly and fund those two dozen full time Ministers. - And I'm sure my GP would be happy too!

But it isn't all about money. The most precious resource we have is us - Unitarian people. People who are prepared to make a difference, by showing acts of kindness, getting involved in social action and social justice and by engaging with neighbours and friends about what we can do to make our world a better place.

Whatever we agree to make our vision for the future, it will need to be resourced. Can we can find these resources by making better use of the buildings and funds we already have, by looking afresh at our 'live' giving and showing our commitment to our faith community with a new financial vigour.

Ralph Waldo Emerson in his book 'The Conduct of Life' said,
"Money often costs too much!"
Wouldn't it be good to show that we have moved beyond that?

And, we all can place some more of our time, our energy and ourselves at the service of a new vision. This may mean re-directing what we do to what is really important for our congregations and our Movement.

Resources? Whatever we decide that vision to be, as we stand at the crossroads, resources need not be our problem.

Rev. Martin Whitell

Embrace New Technology

 Technology and Unitarianism - Oxymoron?

I think it's true to say that the idea of using more technology for any reason can evoke some pretty strong feelings in some people. Perhaps UK Unitarians are even worse than the average in this respect: maybe it's an age thing, I don't know. It seems to me that there are a number of reasons why technology gets invented: perhaps to meet a need or to make something easier or to automate a task. Indeed, perhaps the reason that scares people most is when technology is created to facilitate something completely new and foreign to our established ways of doing things - communicating on Twitter for instance.

Using Twitter seems to be more of a 'young person's game' - however you might be surprised to learn that apart from the quick, simple and free capability it offers for two or more people to have private conversations in 'real-time', sharing comments, pictures and other media, Twitter is also considered a vital part of the customer interaction strategy of many businesses. In fact, it's not just businesses; many other organisations (including churches) are getting in on the act because it's a quick (and mainly free) way to communicate information and respond to questions. The twittering population expects fast answers and because of the way twitter works, the tweets are usually public and easily searchable, so the organisations that use it take care to preserve their image and respond accurately and quickly. Some even scour the 'twittersphere' for tweets that mention their name so they can be sure they know what's being said about them. Please, if you haven't already, consider reaching out to someone who can teach you what Twitter might be able to do for your church or fellowship.

Within some Unitarian gatherings (particularly the more business orientated ones), tweeting what is happening live during the sessions, is not only allowed but usually encouraged. By this means, people that are not present can feel that they are connected to proceedings and can feel something of the enthusiasm or spirit of what is going on. It has even been suggested that this kind of live social media usage should be encouraged during regular Sunday worship and gatherings. Shocking right! Never mind the cries of 'put down your phone' to your kids; maybe it should be 'pick up your phone and tweet, tweet, tweet! - tell the world what a great place we have here and what brilliant things we do here'

Beyond Twitter, I think it's clear that almost everybody is engaging (willingly or otherwise) on Facebook. Unitarians are very active on Facebook. If you are not, I might tentatively offer that maybe you are missing an opportunity to engage with others in the wider (and nearer) Unitarian Movement and possibly even depriving said movement of your own unique and valuable opinion and insight.

If you do not currently use Facebook and are even slightly interested in what you might be missing, might I urge you to reach out to someone that does use it and find out how and why it works? If you can't find someone to assist, call me - or even better come to the Unicoms conference at Hucklow in November and there will be many willing hands to get you going.

OK - so that's all I'm going to say about this new-fangled social media stuff: yes there's a lot more out there that we could be using (and some are) but if you can understand and master Twitter and Facebook and actually use it either for personal connection and growth and / or better still for connection with and growth of the wider organisation, then we are all already winning as a result!

While I think about it, let me just interject two words: 'smart phones'. I'll come back to this, but I will say that with a 'smart phone', you can use just about every tool that I will discuss in this article...

So what about older technology that we could be using? This is the stuff that is perhaps too old and uncool for our kids to be using but that maybe has already passed us by or that we do not see the use of. What could I be talking about?

The first is Skype, the second is Google Hangouts. Both do the same thing in essence and that is to provide a way of having a telephone meeting (conference call) with one or even many people, without having to have everyone physically in the same room. This sort of technology is used every day by most companies across the globe but still the benefits of being able to do this are unknown by many, many people.

Both Skype and Google Hangouts are free programs (also available as free apps on all smart phones). They depend on the user's computer or smart phone to be connected to wi-fi to work. Actually, they can also work over a 3G or 4G mobile data network as well but before doing this, users need to be sure that they have enough data allowance on the mobile plans.

Once a potential Skype user has registered (within the Skype program itself), they can connect to any other Skype user, anywhere in the world, free. All that is required is a network connection and a microphone connected to the computer. Similarly, a user with Google Hangouts can connect to any other Google user worldwide. By the way, any person who has a google account (i.e. gmail account) implicitly also has the capability of using Hangouts).

So what does 'connect' mean in this context? It can mean any or all of three things: messaging, audio or video.
• Messaging simply means typing text messages to the other party (or parties) that you have connected to and receiving their text responses. Rather similar to SMS messages on our phones, except for the fact that you can be connected to multiple other people simultaneously, who all see the conversation on their computer or phone at the same time.
• Audio means that you can connect to one or more people and use your microphone on your computer or phone to talk to those people simultaneously (and they back to you and / or the group also). Unlike dialling one or two people using your phone dialler and the public phone system, such audio sessions on Skype or Google Hangouts are actually being sent over the data network provided by your wi-fi. Because of this, no phone charges are applicable. By the way, you can even use either Skype or Google Hangouts to act like a regular phone and dial other phones (rather than computers or smart phones on a data network) anywhere in the world, but this feature does incur some charges, although these are very reasonable.
• Video (in the same way as audio) means that you can connect to one or more people and use the microphone and WebCam on your computer or phone to both see and talk to those people simultaneously (and they to you and / or the group) - again for free. This means that you are able to actually see who you are having a meeting with and they can see you, almost as if you were face-to-face. This can be very effective and amazingly, is still offered free by both Skype and Google Hangouts. The only real caveat with using these services to do a video meeting is that everyone on the call needs to have a good broadband / network connection or else the quality of the sound and video can be poor and also sometimes people tend to get disconnected from the meeting and have to re-join.

Why have I gone through the above in such detail? The reason is that I want everyone to know that you do not have to have your congregational or other meetings physically in the same room anymore. Using Skype or Hangouts, those people who couldn't get out to any given meeting can still join it remotely, or maybe nobody physically attends it at all and everybody joins in to the meeting from their home computers instead.

Finally, here's a 'Marmite' topic to think about: Use of audio / visual equipment as part of your services and gatherings. Have you considered using a computer, PowerPoint and other media as part of your services? Hook up to a projector and audio system of some description and you have the means to include all sorts of material into your worship. I'm thinking of stuff like pre-recorded hymn tracks (perhaps with film of singers too). Or maybe music/video footage such the Pete Seeger 90th birthday conference rendition of 'We shall overcome' available on YouTube - moving indeed. Recently, I have been to many services that actually have almost all of the service displayed on the screen. This has included appropriate pictures and iconography setting the scene or supporting the theme, music if there is no organist, video for stories or illustrations, responsive readings that all present can see and read together and music / concert videos bringing variety and focus to services / gatherings that simply could not be done any other way.

Another opportunity many of us are missing is to record our worship or gatherings and make them available over the Internet - perhaps on YouTube or even more radical, to stream them live over the Internet as they happen. How many more people could benefit from your messages and participate in your worship if you did this? Unfortunately, I simply do not have space to address these topics here.
So I will leave you with two thoughts: firstly, embracing technology can help you grow by reaching out to and appealing to new audiences that might never otherwise have heard your message.
Secondly, if you don't already have one, get yourself a smart phone (it doesn't have to be expensive). Install Facebook, twitter and other tools on it and join in with the wider Unitarian organisation online. Everyone will be the richer for it.

Finally, if you need help with any of the things I have discussed, call me or send me an email and I'll try to help. Better still, come to Unicoms at The Nightingale Centre in November and have your questions answered in person by any of the 'tech-savvy' helpers who attend and run it. Have fun!

Julian Smith

In Response

From: Dorothy Haughton

As communication is made more and more by email it has to be the responsibility of each congregation to find someone who is email savvy to receive communications and pass them on to the appropriate person. Similarly someone who uses Facebook could print out anything of interest from there. The idea that only one person 'the SECRETARY' is responsible for all forms of communication is outmoded. In some cases the new media person does not even need to be a member of the congregation.

Acknowledge Contribution and Success

What is the point of working for no pay? We all do it for various reasons, in our congregations or in other areas of life. A frequent complaint from those trying to keep their congregations going is that they struggle to recruit volunteers. We need to ask ourselves if we actually acknowledge volunteer contributions and appreciate them enough when they do finally put up their hands.

It's important to remember that some people will have very different motivations for volunteering to you, and so you have to think of different ways to appeal to them.

During a Sunday worship service at Rosslyn Hill Chapel, Hampstead, the separate Children's Programme lights the chalice for their session with the following words:

'We are the chapel of the open minds, the loving hearts and the helping hands.'

One way of looking at people's motivations to volunteer is to think in terms of head people, heart people and hands people. Roughly speaking, head people like to plan and organise; heart people care deeply about the people they work with; and hands people see a job needs to be done and they get stuck in. Which are you?

Now think about how you might appeal to someone in a different category. Although head people care, they will want to know exactly what's expected of them, the time commitment and the goals. Hands people might be willing to help out with doing a reading in a service or a stint on the tea rota but not if they have to fill out a complicated spreadsheet first! Heart people will want to know how their work is going to help those in need.

Try to put yourself in the shoes of someone in another category and see what it takes to appeal to them. It might help to speak to friends and colleagues about their motivations for doing things; if they turn out to have a different viewpoint from you, they will be able to teach you a lot. What friendly advice would they give to someone trying to appeal to them as volunteers? Finally, here are some general tips* on encouraging members of your congregation to get more involved:

Don't ... just try to fill a vacant position.
             make assumptions about the person and their interests.
Do ...    connect the role or task to the mission of the congregation.
             show why this way of serving their community is a good fit for them.
            explain how it will benefit them.
            give an accurate role description showing expectations and time commitment.
            offer support, give feedback and ask for it!

When we get things right, it makes sense to celebrate our successes. How you acknowledge someone's contribution also depends on his or her personality. Some people will appreciate a special ritual in a community worship service whereas others would prefer a simple thank you card. People may volunteer for many different reasons but unless we acknowledge their contribution and celebrate group successes, we risk putting them off next time. Working together on common goals can build thriving Unitarian communities, so let's get going!
Kate Dean

*From the Central East Regional Group, UUA 'Recruiting volunteers Do's and Don'ts' Video - search YouTube.com
Thanks to the participants of the Hands Up! Why Volunteer? workshop at FUSE 2015 for their contributions,

Empower Individuals

I am a member of the Bolton Socialist Club. It is one of the oldest in the country and is still active, supporting and campaigning on issues for the 'common man' - but it is not a church. Unitarians most often also support and campaign on issues for the 'common man', they are a church.

What is the difference?

Many years ago one of my colleagues suggested our churches were more like social clubs, that they were meeting places for middle class, like minded people who met up on a Sunday morning for an unchallenged hour of singing and listening. It was also suggested we were the irrelevant last hurrah of a great reforming religious movement when the name itself identified a person as an influential game changer.

It is indeed a great legacy but visit many of our congregations where there is only a handful of members and it does seem to be a legacy which is almost spent. It makes me ask: What we Unitarians can offer in today's world that others do not? Do we still have a unique selling point?

I learnt a lesson many years ago when the congregation decided to have a flower festival in the Chapel. Someone suggested that as well as the main theme we invited displays to represent the interests of our members. To my surprise these filled a very large section. The Bolton Equality Council, the Women's Refuge, Save the Children, United Nations Association, all founded by present day Unitarians and there were about fifteen other organisations in the display that people supported.

But no one said, 'I do this work because I am a Unitarian'.

They simply did it from the goodness of their hearts and they also happened to be Unitarians but never said so. After that I gave everyone a chalice lapel badge to wear. It made me realise that we are still more than the legacy of our past.

It is just that help is given in an unsung modest Unitarian way. It is not our unique selling point either, charity shop workers and interfaith supporters don't just come from the Unitarians. They come from all walks of life, all faiths and no faiths. I am not sure whether the worship we offer, even the rights of passage we offer, can be claimed as a unique selling point either. I have been to other churches just as happy as ours. I have been to non religious funerals just as sensitive as ours, and weddings.

There are two things we need to do to continue our existence as a church that matters in the world. First we need to transform ourselves into a living tradition and secondly we need focus on meeting the spiritual needs of the modern individual. The Living Tradition is about modifying our worship, using our space and extending our ministry.

Worship should be a joyful, happy experience open to participation and with a message that can be discussed openly. We don't need to be tied to the wheel that is the hymn sandwich. Our space should be an open space where other than worship groups can meet - meditation, yoga, fringe faith groups, support groups and discussion groups.

We shouldn't be afraid of collaborating with other faith groups for the mutual advantage of the wider communities we seek to serve.

Our ministry should be about leadership, not just spiritual leadership, but groups leadership, community leadership. We should not expect to find all these leadership skills invested in one person but be prepared to facilitate training of our own members and to work collaboratively with other churches and organisations.

In the communities around our churches there are many, many individuals who feel lost and isolated. Loneliness is an issue, meeting and socialising with other people is an issue, age is an issue, mind, body and spirit are issues. We have to ask ourselves as a church if we provide space and comfort for people to address those simple questions of, 'Who am I?', 'How can I feel better about myself as an individual and a participator in life?'

I often hear people say, 'But that is about counselling!' I say this is different. It is about spiritual development, finding the confidence and the place to explore those questions of identity and relate them to an overarching reason to belong in the world. Add to that a sense of being in a community where you feel you belong and yet you are still an individual.

How are we to achieve all this? It requires a change of direction, moving away from being just a worshipping community based on a Unitarian tradition. It requires developing a web of interdependence between individual Unitarians, congregations, districts and Essex Hall. We need to share experiences of what works and what doesn't. We need to financially support the training of leaders and the delivery of courses and resources.

We need to share templates for worship and personal spiritual development. We need to promote ourselves - wear the badge and the fly the flag that says who we are and what we stand for.

Above all we need to share a new vision for the future that meets the spiritual and emotional needs of the searching individual. We need to support, enable and empower our own generation to do great deeds because they have found a faith that speaks the truth of life to them?

When we are talking about empowering people it means giving them the opportunity to travel forward in life the way they would wish, being offered opportunities and being able to take them. By encouraging participation in worship we give opportunity to engage in discussion on content and to feel able to volunteer to take part in leading worship. And by offering training and opportunity people can develop skills if they want to. By collaborating with other churches and groups we reach a wider constituency and that gives opportunity in the community where none might have existed before.

Spiritual development gives people the opportunity to know themselves better and the confidence to be involved in the whole of life. I suppose empowerment to me means providing opportunity that allows people to give power to themselves and their life paths.

This is how I believe we can best serve the present age as Unitarians.

Rev. Tony McNeile

Make change happen

Every single one of us knows that we must change. This is true for individual and institutions. Whether we like it or not, realities change around us and if we don't change in response, we become ineffective in relating to our world. We become irrelevant except to the other few who have not changed.

Although we know well about this need to change, we also know how often institutions and individuals fail to make change a reality.One of my favourite examples was the New England ice harvesting and storage industry. For many years, the ice they harvested in winter and sold in the warmer months was the only way to keep fresh food from spoiling quickly. They were successful. This industry created numerous jobs and generated wealth for the owners. And then some darned fool had to ruin it all by inventing mechanical refrigeration!

The way the ice-making industry responded to the threat of innovation is instructive. They worked harder and harder at harvesting ice and keeping it from melting. They even made real technological advances in their harvesting and storage processes.

Although they got more creative about harvesting and storing ice, these companies seemed completely unable to look objectively at the challenging technology of refrigeration. If they had, they might have seen the nature of the threat. Instead, they disparaged the new invention as it slowly improved to challenge them more and more - and eventually destroyed them entirely. They never adopted refrigeration. They disappeared.

Our congregations, in particular, often fail to change to meet the ways of the changing world. Why?

One important part of the answer is that the change comes upon us gradually. There is very rarely a sudden shift that causes us to notice. When the weather gradually gets warmer, we might not take our coats off until we're already wet with perspiration. Slow change is hard to recognise.

A second point is that it is especially hard to change when you have been successful in the past. The ice industry would not have been so hesitant to give up ice harvesting if they had not profited from it handsomely in the past. But wishing will not make the clocks turn back.

A third point is that we develop an overly narrow sense of purpose. The ice companies thought that their purpose was harvesting, storing, and selling ice. What if they had, instead, thought of their purpose as keeping food fresh? Might they now be the leaders in refrigeration, food packaging, and more?

The most important reason for lack of change, however, is that we know change will hurt. We cannot deny that change is accompanied by pain and we run from that pain.

The ice industry executives knew ice-harvesting and ice-storage. That's all they had done their whole careers. They knew nothing about mechanical refrigeration.

Their employees had all the right skills for what they were already doing and none for the new technology. A shift for these companies would have meant many people - including bosses - out of a job. A shift would have meant pain.

Ice customers were of little help in helping the ice companies see the need for change. On the contrary, their customers were probably telling them about how much they preferred natural ice and how reluctant they would be to get mechanical refrigeration. Of course, the companies were only hearing from the dwindling number of customers that remained loyal to naturally harvest ice and thus remained customers. The majority were soon happy with their cold, humming, full refrigerators and the ice companies never heard from them.

All of this is relevant to our congregations.

Change has come upon us slowly. There was a time when freedom, reason, and tolerance for radical concepts. It was hard to find a good, inspiring talk. Slowly, change came and what made us different was now part of the basic assumptions of our society. Gradually, taste in music changed. Gradually, attention spans shortened and great talks could increasingly be found for free at home via the Internet. None of it happened suddenly, but it has happened.

Like the ice-harvesting industry, we have also been successful in the past. The grand Unitarian chapels distributed around this land bear testament to the great success of the mid 19th century. The great names we reverently utter remind us too of a glorious heritage. It is hard to change when the past looks so bright and the dream of the return of those times remains so enticing.

Like the ice industry, we can have a narrow view of our purpose. Is it to put on a service on Sundays with some hymns, readings, and a sermon? Is it to keep a building in good shape? What if we understood our purpose more broadly as, for example, "transforming lives for the better in community" or "teaching peace, justice, and love"? How differently might we begin to act?

But, again, the most important impediment to change is that change hurts.

Our congregations are well-adapted for the old ways. Our ministers are trained for a particular way of doing church. (I can assure you that we ministers do not relish any change that requires leaders with skills we lack and might threaten to replace us.) The leaders of our congregations and our other institutions, like our ministers, are comfortable with leading as they always have. They don't welcome seeing much of what they've learned through the years become irrelevant. Their influence and ability to help would be undermined.

And the members of our congregations are members because they are among the ones who like the old ways. If they didn't, they - like the customers who abandoned buying ice - would not be present there to remind us of the need to change.

Change is hard.

And change sometimes does happen. When it does, it is because of leaders who are able to tolerate pain - their own and that of others close to them - in order to follow a greater vision. Think of Gandhi, Mandela, and Martin Luther King, Jr. They moved mountains, but not because they were superb tacticians or knew how best to advertise their movements in social media. They were great because they were able to project a non-anxious, visionary presence that overcame the enormous anxiety that would otherwise have held their people back.

In our congregations, such leaders may be clergy or not. Sometimes, they may not even have formal power in their congregations. They may not be able to preach or sing or build a website or keep a ledger of accounts, but it is not such skills that make them successful. These leaders are secure in themselves and able to exist in the midst of anxiety without succumbing to it.

The late rabbi, therapist, and leadership advisor Edwin Friedman’s revolutionary thinking about leadership is elucidated in his two books “Generation to Generation” and “A Failure of Nerve” Friedman introduces such leaders and calls them “self-differentiated.” They are great leaders not because of special skills, but because of their ability to be the non-anxious, firm, resolute, presence in an anxious community system.

And strong they must be! As Friedman explains, any self-differentiated leader successfully taking a community forward will be subject to sabotage and great resistance. As clergy in congregational contexts, doing the right thing for the institution they love rather than keeping people happy in the moment may well cost them their jobs.

Making change happen. The answer is leadership - not specific skills, but specific ways of being that are borne of an inner strength, confidence, and adherence to a vision that is more compelling than our very natural desire to avoid discomfort.

We don’t need tactics. The tactics are out there written in detail in countless books and available in hundreds of videos. We need to recruit and train and develop leaders who can bear the discomfort in themselves and others as the pain of change emerges and we need congregations willing to allow a leader to emerge and to lead.

Rev. Andy Pakula